Wednesday, May 11, 2005

Respect vs. Popularity

Agnosto. asks, "Given the choice, would you prefer to be liked or respected?" He elaborates:
I know that some of the people who are "popular" are also not well respected. I am thinking of one coworker in particular who is rather popular (has people stopping by his cubicle all the time and so on), but people make fun of him behind his back for being dumber than a brick wall and semi-useless at his job.

My answer depends on what is meant by "liked". I think that either one of respect or popularity on its own is relatively worthless. We should distinguish genuine friendship from both of these. As I see it, although it's possible to respect (part of?) someone who you do not like, the converse does not hold. You cannot truly like someone you don't respect. That is, respect is essential to genuine friendship. On the other hand, "popularity" - understood as sheer quantity of time spent socializing - seems far less important.

But my opinions should probably be taken with a pinch of salt. After all, I'm extremely introverted. I actually don't like being surrounded by people all the time (it's nothing personal, I just find social settings awfully draining). So I'd be curious to hear what more, er... normal... people think of this question.

P.S. I absolutely cannot recommend the Jonathan Rauch article enough. It's very funny, and also helps correct some common misconceptions about introversion. Do read it.

3 comments:

  1. My post had far less to do with true friendship (which, for me, is exceedingly rare) than simple popularity. The question (to myself, really) was would I prefer having people seek me out for my (social) company or would I rather that people have a high opinion of aspects of me which I find important?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think the real question is;

    Which one should I choose if I just want most people to leave me alone?

    If people would actually like me (which I doubt) then they would be more likely to talk to (read as annoy) me, and they may be less likely to talk to me if they merely respect me.
    So I will take respect.

    Note, this is a completely instrumental argument. I could not care less about whether people like or respect me. I doubt there is value in being liked or respected at all. But there may be value in the things that one is being liked or respected for. But hey, I would probably doubt that too.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'm not normal, so add salt :)

    I can't like someone I don't respect. But I use the word like to mean genuine friendships.

    Ignoring my inconsistencies over whether I like/respect others, I would prefer it if other people liked me rather than respected me. This is despite the fact that interacting with people is usually draining.

    Love the Rauch article!

    ReplyDelete

Visitors: check my comments policy first.
Non-Blogger users: If the comment form isn't working for you, email me your comment and I can post it on your behalf. (If your comment is too long, first try breaking it into two parts.)